I always enjoy visiting Fat Olives when I’m in Flagstaff, Arizona! The staff, vibrant atmosphere and infectious vibe are always fun and a feast for the senses. Our reservations were promptly acknowledged and my wife and I were whisked to our table. Unfortunately the table was roughly the size of a postage stamp. The corner we were at behind the bar only added to the feeling of claustrophobia. I was shocked when my Caesar Salad was heaped with a topping of what was essentially crouton dust. It’s ground into a gritty, sandy like texture here. I much prefer a traditional, crispy crouton. I’m not sure who thought this was a good culinary idea, but I hope I’m never served a salad like that again. It only made matters worse that the romaine greens were quite underdressed.
The food here comes out way too fast. I was only 5 or 6 bites into my giant crumb covered salad when our main dishes came out. Given that we were sitting at such a tiny table it only made matters more cluttered, awkward and uncomfortable. Not how you want to feel on a nice evening out. I had the Rigatoni dish which is baked off with Italian sausage and melted cheeses. I appreciated that it was served bubbly hot, sadly though the pasta was overcooked way past al dente. Had an unfortunate mushy mouthfeel. We did enjoy the Crème Brûlée Cheesecake, however the name is somewhat of a misnomer. It’s basically just a slice of a New York style cheesecake with a caramel drizzle. I think next time I’ll just stick with one of their reliable and tasty pizzas.

Leave a Reply